Brisk, Mussar, and Chassidus: Hehudi In a NUTSHELL

I received the following question from a reader:

General Questions

In a nutshell, for each question, what is wrong with;

  • Mussar?
  • Brisk?
  • Chassiduth in general?
  • Breslov in particular?

Answer:
The case for a conservative/paleo/originalist Judaism is simple.
Since ideals are ordinal, it is a logical necessity (and historical observation) any time a new ideal is preached, it must supplant the earlier scale of ideals: “antinomianism”. The Jewish problems with “revivals” such as Brisk, Mussar, Chassidus, and so on, are but manifestations of this axiom.
As for Breslov, although the individuals may have problems, especially due to misinterpretations of doctrine, the system itself is not revolutionary (in the negative sense), since Breslov explicitly leaves Halacha alone.
And again, this is chiefly about ideas, not specific Jews. Some Jews may think they are following these perversions, by misreading the texts to mean nothing heretical, and adopting only harmless mannerisms, while other Jews have ostensibly no connection, yet tragically absorbed these poisons.

Ron Paul: The ‘Afghanistan Papers’ Won’t Bring Justice, Either!

Afghanistan War – The Crime of the Century

“We were devoid of a fundamental understanding of Afghanistan. We didn’t know what we were doing.” So said Gen. Douglas Lute, who oversaw the US war on Afghanistan under Presidents Bush and Obama. Eighteen years into the longest war in US history, we are finally finding out, thanks to thousands of pages of classified interviews on the war published by the Washington Post last week, that General Lute’s cluelessness was shared by virtually everyone involved in the war.

What we learned in what is rightly being called the “Pentagon Papers” of our time, is that hundreds of US Administration officials – including three US Presidents – knowingly lied to the American people about the Afghanistan war for years. This wasn’t just a matter of omitting some unflattering facts. This was about bald-faced lying about a war they knew was a disaster from almost day one.

Remember President Bush’s Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld? Remember how supremely confident he was at those press conferences, acting like the master of the universe? Here’s what he told the Pentagon’s special inspector general who compiled these thousands of interviews on Afghanistan: “I have no visibility into who the bad guys are.”

It is not only members of the Bush, Obama, and Trump Administrations who are guilty of this massive fraud. Falsely selling the Afghanistan war as a great success was a bipartisan activity on Capitol Hill. In the dozens of hearings I attended in the House International Relations Committee, I do not recall a single “expert” witness called who told us the truth. Instead, both Republican and Democrat-controlled Congresses called a steady stream of neocon war cheerleaders to lie to us about how wonderfully the war was going. Victory was just around the corner, they all promised. Just a few more massive appropriations and we’d be celebrating the end of the war.

Congress and especially Congressional leadership of both parties are all as guilty as the three lying Administrations. They were part of the big lie, falsely presenting to the American people as “expert” witnesses only those bought-and-paid-for Beltway neocon think tankers.

What is even more shocking than the release of this “smoking gun” evidence that the US government wasted two trillion dollars and killed more than three thousand Americans and more than 150,000 Afghans while lying through its teeth about the war is that you could hear a pin drop in the mainstream media about it. Aside from the initial publication in the Washington Post, which has itself been a major cheerleader for the war in Afghanistan, the mainstream media has shown literally no interest in what should be the story of the century.

We’ve wasted at least half a year on the Donald Trump impeachment charade – a conviction desperately in search of a crime. Meanwhile one of the greatest crimes in US history will go unpunished. Not one of the liars in the “Afghanistan Papers” will ever be brought to justice for their crimes. None of the three presidents involved will be brought to trial for these actual high crimes. Rumsfeld and Lute and the others will never have to fear justice. Because both parties are in on it. There is no justice.

Just days after the “Afghanistan Papers” were published, only 48 Members of Congress voted against the massive military spending of the 2020 National Defense Authorization Act. They continue as if nothing happened. They will continue lying to us and ripping us off if we let them.

From LRC, here.

Haggadat Hapesah: Bring Korban Pesach Back Into Your Seder!

Pre-Order Haggadat Hapesah!

WhatsApp Image 2019-12-18 at 15.34.10.jpeg

  • “What? Another Haggada!? Aren’t there enough in the market already?”
  • “Korban Pesah? Is that even relevant?”
  • “What do you mean some things will change? We’ve been doing the same Seder for 2000 years!”Haggadat Hapesah by Rabbi Avi Grossman is the first Haggada to be used at a seder with the Korban Pesach as the rightful centerpiece, and includes a remarkably familiar but updated text, simple instructions, and explanations regarding the practices that were once done at the seder and will, God willing, be renewed soon.

    Haggadat Hapesah is approved by the Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rabbi David Lau, and many other scholars.

    In order to get the first edition in stores as soon as possible, as of now copies of Haggadat Hapesah need to be paid for in advance.

    Pre-order Haggadat Hapesah here: https://forms.gle/fHsKZoqM7hpF8uAcA

Avi

״מה? עוד הגדה?! אין כבר מספיק הגדות בשוק? מה מיוחד בהגדה הזאת?״ ״קרבן פסח? זה לא רלוונטי כיום!״״מה זאת אומרת שליל הסדר ישתנה? אנחנו מסדרים את אותו הסדר כבר אלפיים שנה! זה  כל כך מבלבל.״

הגדת הפסח של הרב אב״י גרוסמן היא ההגדה הראשונה עם הנוסח וכל ההסברים לסדר שבמרכזו קרבן הפסח – שבע״ה נזכה להקריב בקרוב, אמן.
הגדת הפסח נושאת מכתבי ברכה מאת הרב הראשי לישראל הרב דוד לאו, עוד גדולים אחרים, והיא מיועדת לפתוח שיח חשוב.

כדי להוציא את ההגדה לאור לקראת הפסח הבעל׳׳ט, אנו מ״מה? עוד הגדה?! אין כבר מספיק הגדות בשוק? מה מיוחד בהגדה הזאת?״ ״קרבן פסח? זה לא רלוונטי כיום!״״מה זאת אומרת שליל הסדר ישתנה? אנחנו מסדרים את אותו הסדר כבר אלפיים שנה! זה  כל כך מבלבל.״

הגדת הפסח של הרב אב״י גרוסמן היא ההגדה הראשונה עם הנוסח וכל ההסברים לסדר שבמרכזו קרבן הפסח – שבע״ה נזכה להקריב בקרוב, אמן.

הגדת הפסח נושאת מכתבי ברכה מאת הרב הראשי לישראל הרב דוד לאו, עוד גדולים אחרים, והיא מיועדת לפתוח שיח חשוב.

כדי להוציא את ההגדה לאור לקראת הפסח הבעל׳׳ט, אנו מכינים מהדורה ראשונה לזריזים – דרך הזמנה מוקדמת.

אנחנו מחוייבים להאמין, להתפלל, ולצפות לגאולה. להאמין שיש מציאות אחרת, אידאלית, שהיא קרובה אלינו. כל השנים שעברו אמרנו ״לשנה הבאה בירושלים,״ אז השנה הזאת בירושלים.

להזמנה מוקדמת, לחץ כאן: https://forms.gle/BhBCZspbP2hfjgFT6

(בע״ה ההגדה תישלח לפני פסח הבעל׳׳ט.)

From Rabbi Avi Grossman, here.

THIS WORLD Is ‘The Best of All Possible Worlds’!

Question: If you could live forever, would you and why?

Answer: “I would not live forever, because we should not live forever, because if we were supposed to live forever, then we would live forever, but we cannot live forever, which is why I would not live forever.”

– Miss Alabama in the 1994 Miss USA contest