Warning: Being ‘Karov Lamalchus’ is RISKY

The Mishna in Avos 2:3 states:

הוו זהירין ברשות, שאין מקרבין לו לאדם אלא לצרך עצמן. נראין כאוהבין בשעת הנאתן. ואין עומדין לו לאדם בשעת דחקו

My translation:

Beware the authorities, for they embrace a man solely for own benefit. They appear friendly to him when it suits their purposes, but do not save him in his hour of distress.

I haven’t read it, but this book seems to illustrate this Mishna: “The Fatal Embrace: Jews and the State” by Benjamin Ginsberg (among related insights!).

The Rabbis Follow the Achiya Hashiloni Model

See this:

In 2010 I wrote Rav Chaim Kanievsky shlita a letter asking if he really signed on a letter supporting an indicted child abuser. He replied that he signs on whatever his own Rabbis sign on. His handwritten response can be seen on this blog here. I subsequently sent Rav Chaim a letter respectfully challenging his reliance on his Rav and his issuing decisions based on incomplete knowledge of the situation. I quoted Rav Yaakov Kaminetzky as saying: “דעת תורה אהין דעת תורה אהער דער פאקטס מוז מין העב’ן”, and the following from Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg, the Seredei Aish, who wrote:

יודעים אנו על פי הניסיון כי מסביב לכיסאו של אדם גדול שורצים ורבים בריות שפלות, מין רמשים קטנים, אשר קטנותן תהיה להן למבטח כי לא תֵראנה ולא תִמצאנה, ועל כן יכולות הן, בהאפילן על עצמן בטליתו של ה”גדול”, לעשות כמעשה הרמש, ולרדוף אחרי כל אדם ישר באין כל סכנה לנפשן. ויש לפעמים אשר אנשים ישרים נפגעים על ידי גאון מפורסם מבלי הבין את חטאתם ופשעם, כסבורים הם שזאת היא “עקיצת עקרב” ומתמרמרים על הגאון, בעוד שבעיקר הדבר אין זאת אלא “נשיכה של שועל” היוצא מבית קודשי הקודשים של גאון, או לחישת נחש המתחמם בחיקו…” (מתוך ספר לפרקים)
Excerpted from Rationalist Judaism, here.
Read the rest!

More is Less

Raising the Bar Beyond the Average Person’s Reach

Posted on:October 13, 2015

Posted by:Rabbi Shmuel Gluck

Since High school and post High School interviews are looming in the coming weeks for both boys and girls, this article intends to help parents decide which are the most appropriate schools for their children. (I’ve written an extensive article describing my approach to school placements, and will gladly forward it to anyone interested.)

Several parts of this article may seem as if they’re directed towards changing the Yeshiva system, but they aren’t. I often tell parents that it’s not their responsibility to grade, judge, or fix, the Chinuch System. Their only job is to be objective as to what’s best for their children, and follow through with those conclusions.

Many people believe that for children (This article speaks to parents, but applies equally to adults, and their aspirations for personal growth.) to reach their maximum potential, they must be presented with increasingly higher standards. I’ve found that this attitude, the unrealistically raising of what will be defined as the norm, is the belief of many of our schools, families, and individuals.

Classroom hours are increasing, the calendar is expanding, and there’s pressure to learn outside of mandatory class time. The image of a Ben Torah/Chassidishe student in the minds of many people has been expanded beyond what most people would’ve imagined when they were younger.

Continue reading…

From Areivim, here.

The Uncomfortable Truth About the DDT Ban

The worldwide crusade to ban the pesticide DDT is a classic example. This crusade was begun by the much revered Rachel Carson, whose best-selling book “Silent Spring” was based on the premise that DDT’s adverse effects on the eggs of song birds would end up wiping out these species. After that, springtime would no longer be marked by birds singing; hence the silent spring.

Rachel Carson and the environmentalists she inspired have succeeded in getting DDT banned in country after country, for which they have received the accolades of many, not least their own accolades. But, in terms of the actual consequences of that crusade, there has not been a mass murderer executed in the past half-century who has been responsible for as many deaths of human beings as the sainted Rachel Carson. The banning of DDT has led to a huge resurgence of malaria in the Third World, with deaths rising into the millions.

An excerpt of Thomas Sowell from Town Hall, here.

Confirmation can be found in J. Gordon Edwards’, DDT: A Case Study in Scientific Fraud, Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons 2004.